Tailored Anti-Smoking Messages Resonate Better With LGBTQ+ Young Adults
New research from the Health Communication & Equity Lab calls for moving beyond one-size-fits-all approaches in public health campaigns targeting LGBTQ+ young adults.
In the U.S., LGBTQ+ adults smoke cigarettes at significantly higher rates than their cisgender and heterosexual peers. "These health inequalities make it urgent to develop the need for effective anti-smoking interventions intended for targeted toward LGBTQ+ young adults," says Associate Professor Andy Tan, director of Health Communication & Equity Lab at the Annenberg School for Communication at the University of Pennsylvania.
A new study by Tan and colleagues, including Qijia Ye, doctoral candidate at the Annenberg School, investigated what makes anti-smoking messages tailored toward LGBTQ+ young adults resonate with them. The study, published in Nicotine & Tobacco Research, discovered that LGBTQ+ young adults resonate more strongly with anti-smoking messages when the visual imagery in those messages reflects their own gender identity.
What Did The Study Do?
The study examined whether LGBTQ+ young adults felt that anti-smoking messages were intended for them — a concept researchers call "perceived targetedness" — based on the gender expressions depicted in campaign imagery.
The team conducted two experiments. In the first, 461 LGBTQ+ adults aged 18-30 were randomly assigned to evaluate eight images selected from a pool of 80 images, which they were told would be used in anti-tobacco messaging. The researchers chose images of young adults with diverse gender expressions: transgender/nonbinary, feminine, masculine, or an image comprising a group of adults representing multiple gender expressions.
Participants were asked to rate the perceived targetedness of each image and other variables, including whether they liked the image. For example, participants were asked to rate how strongly they agree or disagree with the statement, “I would feel this message was intended for people like me.”
In experiment two, 1,190 LGBTQ+ adults aged 18-30 were randomly assigned to one of four gender expression conditions: transgender/nonbinary, feminine, masculine, or multiple genders, and viewed anti-smoking messages that included an image from one of the six top-ranked images from experiment one.
The images were paired with text presenting an anti-smoking argument as well as a QR code directing viewers to get more information on quitting smoking, a logo, and the slogan of the project (“LGBTQ+ health is our focus.”)
What Did the Study Find?
Participants reported significantly higher perceived targetedness when the gender expressions in a message matched their own gender identity. Messages featuring multiple gender expressions also performed well, suggesting that inclusive portrayals can resonate across subgroups within the LGBTQ+ community.
What’s Next?
“Our research shows that health communicators cannot treat the LGBTQ+ community as a monolith in smoking interventions," Ye says. “Our results show that tailoring messages to specific gender identities within the community is crucial to reaching diverse audiences effectively. By respecting the distinctive characteristics of different groups within the LGBTQ+ community and designing messages accordingly, communicators are more likely to create campaigns that truly connect and that can make a real difference in health outcomes."